| UFC Fight Night: Emmett vs. Murphy | Brad Tavares | 1046 →1066(+20) | Gerald Meerschaert | 1041 →1022(-19) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Royval vs. Taira | JunYong Park | 1067 →1087(+20) | Brad Tavares | 1066 →1046(-20) | Middleweight | Loss | S-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Hermansson vs. Pyfer | Gregory Rodrigues | 1059 →1085(+26) | Brad Tavares | 1091 →1066(-25) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 292: Sterling vs. O'Malley | Brad Tavares | 1069 →1091(+22) | Chris Weidman | 1101 →1080(-21) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Pavlovich vs. Blaydes | Bruno Silva | 1048 →1075(+27) | Brad Tavares | 1096 →1069(-27) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 276: Adesanya vs. Cannonier | Dricus Du Plessis | 1047 →1072(+25) | Brad Tavares | 1120 →1096(-24) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC 264: Poirier vs. McGregor 3 | Brad Tavares | 1100 →1120(+20) | Omari Akhmedov | 1100 →1080(-20) | Middleweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC 257: Poirier vs. McGregor | Brad Tavares | 1081 →1100(+19) | Antonio Carlos Junior | 1058 →1039(-19) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 244: Masvidal vs. Diaz | Edmen Shahbazyan | 1061 →1087(+26) | Brad Tavares | 1107 →1081(-26) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Undefeated Finale | Israel Adesanya | 1041 →1066(+25) | Brad Tavares | 1132 →1107(-25) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Poirier vs. Gaethje | Brad Tavares | 1114 →1132(+18) | Krzysztof Jotko | 1043 →1025(-18) | Middleweight | Win | KO |
| UFC 216: Ferguson vs. Lee | Brad Tavares | 1092 →1114(+22) | Thales Leites | 1112 →1091(-21) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Redemption Finale | Brad Tavares | 1072 →1092(+20) | Elias Theodorou | 1080 →1059(-21) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 203: Miocic vs. Overeem | Brad Tavares | 1053 →1072(+19) | Caio Magalhaes | 1041 →1022(-19) | Middleweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Miocic vs Hunt | Robert Whittaker | 1046 →1072(+26) | Brad Tavares | 1078 →1053(-25) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC 182: Jones vs Cormier | Brad Tavares | 1056 →1078(+22) | Nate Marquardt | 1086 →1065(-21) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Bader vs Saint Preux | Tim Boetsch | 1040 →1066(+26) | Brad Tavares | 1082 →1056(-26) | Middleweight | Loss | KO |
| UFC on FOX: Werdum vs Browne | Yoel Romero | 1071 →1093(+22) | Brad Tavares | 1104 →1082(-22) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Rockhold vs Philippou | Brad Tavares | 1088 →1104(+16) | Lorenz Larkin | 1008 →992(-16) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC Fight Night: Condit vs Kampmann 2 | Brad Tavares | 1071 →1088(+17) | Robert McDaniel | 1023 →1005(-18) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC on FUEL TV: Silva vs. Stann | Brad Tavares | 1054 →1071(+17) | Riki Fukuda | 1000 →983(-17) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC on FUEL TV: Struve vs Miocic | Brad Tavares | 1036 →1054(+18) | Tom Watson | 1000 →982(-18) | Middleweight | Win | S-DEC |
| UFC on FUEL TV: Korean Zombie vs Poirier | Brad Tavares | 1018 →1036(+18) | Dongi Yang | 986 →968(-18) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
| UFC 132: Cruz vs Faber | Aaron Simpson | 1038 →1058(+20) | Brad Tavares | 1038 →1018(-20) | Middleweight | Loss | U-DEC |
| UFC 125: Resolution | Brad Tavares | 1020 →1038(+18) | Phil Baroni | 950 →932(-18) | Middleweight | Win | KO |
| The Ultimate Fighter: Team Liddell vs Team Ortiz Finale | Brad Tavares | 1000 →1020(+20) | Seth Baczynski | 1000 →980(-20) | Middleweight | Win | U-DEC |
